Thursday, July 15, 2010

NIMH Research Domain Criteria Meeting

I spent the last two days in Bethesda at the first workshop of the NIMH RDoC project, which was one of the most interesting scientific meetings I've been to in quite a while.  This project is meant to address two major problems in psychiatry.  First, there is widespread dissatisfaction with the current categorical approaches to psychiatric diagnoses, and a growing realization that better understanding of these disorders requires a dimensional (rather than categorical) perspective (e.g., Kraemer, 2007).  Second, there is  an increasing realization of the need to ground psychiatric diagnoses in neuroscience (Miller, 2010). The goal of the RDoC project is to help determine what the best candidates are for neuroscientifically validated dimensions that are most likely to be relevant to mental disorders.


This workshop was the first of several, each of which will focus on a particular construct or domain.  This first meeting was focused on the concept of "working memory."  The group was quite broad, from researchers who study working memory in mental disorders to neurobiologists who study the molecular basis of sustained activity in rodents.  The first charge of the group was to come up with a definition of working memory.  Given how prevalent this concept is in the literature (more than 11,000 hits in PubMed), it might seem that a definition would be obvious, but it took the better part of an hour for each of the two  working groups to come up with a definition that most of us could agree on.  Remarkably, the definitions generated independently by each group were very similar!  A summary of the consensus definition (generated through additional discussion of the whole group) has been entered as the new definition of the "working memory" concept in the Cognitive Atlas and can be found here


Much of the remainder of the workshop focused on characterizing the tasks, neural systems, molecules, and genes that are relevant to working memory.  Although each group came up with lists of tasks that were thought to best capture the construct of working memory, there was some trepidation about publishing this list, lest it become a blessing for the uncritical use of these tasks as "working memory tasks".  Rather, the group focused more on discussing what task features are most important for ensuring construct validity of tasks meant to measure working memory.  These will be published soon as part of the output from the workshop.


Another interesting point of discussion centered around how to relate the different levels of analysis, from molecules to neuropsychological tests.  The challenge comes in thinking about how construct mechanistically realistic links between molecular constructs (such as allelic variation in the COMT gene) and behavior (such as performance on the N-back task).  Drawing from the approach that has been developed within the UCLA Consortium for Neuropsychiatric Phenomics, Bob Bilder and I argued that this should be thought of in terms of links between successive levels of structure. For example, we can establish links between cognitive processes and neural systems, between neural systems and cellular systems, and so on down to genes and environmental influences. These different levels can then be traversed to provide a sophisticated mechanistic understanding of how we can get from genes to cognitive function.


Finally, there was a good bit of interesting discussion about the need for measures of working memory that are better validated, both conceptually and psychometrically. There was a clear undercurrent of dissatisfaction with the degree to which the imaging literature has relied on tasks that are not well validated in either of these senses (the N-back task being the poster child for this).  There seems to be great interest in developing a battery of validated tests, and maybe even greater interest in the potential of using these for online testing of large groups across studies.  For example, this seems to be the only realistic way to get sample sizes large enough to make well-powered genome-wide association analyses feasible for cognitive phenotypes.


The RDoC meeting was particularly exciting because of how well it dovetails with the Cognitive Atlas Project.  Getting researchers involved in clarifying their concepts and specifying how they relate to tasks and other levels of analysis is exactly what this project was designed to do.  I have already entered a good bit of the knowledge that was generated in this first RDoC workshop into the system, and I hope that we can make the Cognitive Atlas a repository for all of the knowledge that is generated in the subsequent RDoC workshops as well.  It was heartening to see that the framework that we have developed for representing this kind of knowledge is so well aligned to the kinds of knowledge building that NIMH clearly sees as essential for progress.



13 comments:

  1. The meeting described made me think of concrete examples that illustrate the associated multi-level concepts, which are closely linked to recent developments in multi-set analysis approaches. A particulalry nice concrete example of the multi-level view is found in Hariri A. Annu. Rev. Neurosci. 32:225–47, 2009.
    I wondered if Russ and/or others know of other concrete demonstrations of this multi-level view with intermediate levels actually filled in with data, or even analyzed with multi-set techniques. Most of the example I am aware of cover only two levels (e.g., genes - neuroimaging) or occur at the same level (e.g., MRI - fMRI - EEG).

    ReplyDelete
  2. I haven’t any word to appreciate this post.....Really i am impressed from this post....the person who create this post it was a great human..thanks for shared this with us.
    obsessive compulsive disorder treatment

    ReplyDelete

  3. Cool post, very interesting your work. I envy you for good, as I am a big fan of Bethesda, and very much like to spend with them a joint working day. I work in the field of cloud servers and would like to know how promising gaming company to conduct its work through the cloud server data room software

    ReplyDelete
  4. Flipkart is Offering Cashback Offers Flipkart hdfc cashback offers You will get upto 75% Discount

    Flipkart is Offering Cashback Offers Flipkart SBI Cashback Offer You will get upto 75% Discount

    Flipkart is Offering Cashback Offers Flipkart AXIS Cashback Offer You will get upto 75% Discount

    Flipkart is one of the biggest world wide eCommerce Site so here you will getFlipkart big billion day offers

    Flipkart is one of the biggest world wide eCommerce Site so here you will getflipkart bank cashback offersso

    Flipkart is one of the biggest world wide eCommerce Site so here you will getFlipkart bank offersso

    ReplyDelete
  5. I really impressed after read this because of some quality work and informative thoughts . I just wanna say thanks for the writer and wish you all the best for coming!. SpeakEasyTherapyLV

    ReplyDelete
  6. I'm glad I found this web site, I couldn't find any knowledge on this matter prior to.Also operate a site and if you are ever interested in doing some visitor writing for me if possible feel free to let me know, im always look for people to check out my web site. where can you buy herbalife

    ReplyDelete
  7. nice post.super article .iam follow your website.


    Flipkart CashBack Offers-SBI, HDFC, ICICI, Citibank Cards&Flipkart HDFC Cards Offers"
    flipkart bank offers,flipkart cash back coupons,flipkart offers 2018,flipkart coupons 2018,flipkart cashback offers 2018,flipkart cashback offers,flipkart cash back offers,flipkart cashback coupons,flipkart cashback,Flipkart Cashback Offers,Flipkart Bank Offers,Flipkart Deals 2018, flipkart upcoming offers on mobiles, hdfc credit card offers on flipkart 2018 flipkart sbi offer big billion day, flipkart hdfc offer, flipkart hdfc offer august 2018 sbi flipkart offer 2018 flipkart icici offer


    FLIPKART CITIBANK OFFER,FLIPKART ICICI OFFER,
    SBI CARD OFFERS ON FLIPKART,
    FLIPKART CASHBACK OFFER TODAY,FLIPKART CREDIT CARD OFFERS,
    ALL BANK CREDIT CARD OFFERS,HDFC CREDIT CARD OFFERS ON FLIPKART,
    AXIS BANK CREDIT CARD OFFERS ON FLIPKART,
    CITIBANK CREDIT CARD OFFERS ON FLIPKART,SBI FLIPKART OFFER



    Flipkart Cashback Offers||Flipkart Bank Offers||Flipkart Deals 2018||flipkart upcoming offers,"
    "Flipkart Cashback Offers || Flipkart Bank Offers || Flipkart Deals 2018 ||" "flipkart upcoming offers on mobiles, hdfc credit card offers on flipkart 2018, sbi credit card offers on flipkart today, flipkart hdfc offer terms and conditions, sbi flipkart offer 2018, flipkart cashback phonepe, flipkart hdfc offer august 2018, flipkart icici offer




    "cashback,vouchers,coupons,discounts,offers,deals,promo codes,&Cashback Offers"
    "cash back coupons "Coupons, Discounts & Offers on 1500+ Shopping Sites in India. Get Extra Cashback Everytime You Shop Online using Coupons of Amazon, Flipkart, Tata CLiQ, Nykaa etc."cashback, vouchers, coupons, discounts, offers, deals, promo codes,Coupons, Promo Codes & Cashback Offers



    Offersable - Cash Back Offers | Discount Coupons | Bank Offers | Promo Codes.
    Find best Discount Coupons, Cashback Offers, Hot Deals Bank Offers for all major e-commerce stores in the India



    Amazon cashback offers 2018Cashback Deals with sbi,hdfc,icici,axis banks,credit&debit card,
    Amazon Cashback Offers 2018 Upto 65% Cashback Deals, AMAZON CASHBACK OFFERS 2018, DISCOUNT COUPON OFFERS 2018, Amazon cashback offers with sbi hdfc icici axis banks credit&debit card offers more. amazon cashback offers2018,amazon india cashback,amazon offers on mobiles,amazon cashback2018,amazon offers 2018

    ReplyDelete
  8. flipkart is Offering Cashback Offers Flipkart hdfc cashback offers You will get upto 75% Discount

    Flipkart is Offering Cashback Offers Flipkart SBI Cashback Offer You will get upto 75% Discount

    Flipkart is Offering Cashback Offers Flipkart AXIS Cashback Offer You will get upto 75% Discount

    Flipkart is Offering Cashback Offers Flipkart YES Cashback Offer You will get upto 75% Discount

    Flipkart is one of the biggest world wide eCommerce Site so here you will getFlipkart big billion day offers

    Flipkart is one of the biggest world wide eCommerce Site so here you will getflipkart bank cashback offersso


    Flipkart cashback offers on mobiles,
    Flipkart cashback offers,
    Flipkart cashback coupons,
    Flipkart upcoming offers on mobiles,
    Flipkart HDFC cashback offers,
    Flipkart SBI cashback offers,
    Flipkart AXIS cashback offers,
    Flipkart Citibank cashback offers,
    Flipkart cashback on mobiles,
    Flipkart cashback offers today,
    Flipkart big billion day cashback offers,
    Flipkart big billion days cashback offers,
    big billion day cashback offers,
    Flipkart big billion days offers,
    flipkart cashback on mobiles,
    flipkart citibank offer,
    sbi credit card offers on flipkart today,
    flipkart upcoming offers on mobiles,
    hdfc credit card offers on flipkart,
    flipkart upcoming big billion day,
    flipkart upcoming sale,
    sbi credit card offers on mobiles,
    flipkart offers today,
    flipkart offers on mobiles,
    flipkart offers today mobile phones,
    flipkart cashback offers,
    flipkart cashback coupons,
    flipkart sale today offer,
    flipkart cashback offers today,
    cashback offers,
    flipkart cashback offer today

    ReplyDelete
  9. Wow! Such an amazing and helpful post this is. I really really love it. It’s so good and so awesome. I am just amazed. I hope that you continue to do your work like this in the future also




    Flipkart SBI offers on mobiles,
    Flipkart SBI cashback Offer

    ReplyDelete
  10. We are a reputable writing company psychologypaper.com of international experience with creation of different types of essays for students of all levels of education. We have a team of professional writers of all possible scientific areas. That is why our agency is always confident about our essays being of the top quality. The assignments we provide for our customers always contain relevant information and facts.

    Due to a number of factors, the mental medicine is nowadays one of extremely popular scientific directions as long as scientists from all over the world explore the reasons for psychological problems, mental health argumentative essay, and the ways to overcome and treat them. People’s psychological peculiarities, behavior, and reactions to various factors and circumstances are under discussion and are carefully examined.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Thank you for giving me better understanding of this meeting! wuxiaworld

    ReplyDelete